Operative Techniques in Orthopaedic Surgery (4 Volume Set) 1st Edition

503. Modified Brostrom and Brostrom-Evans Procedures

Paul J. Hecht, Justin S. Cummins, Mark E. Easley, and Dean C. Taylor

DEFINITION

images Lateral ankle injuries are among the most common musculoskeletal injuries in the athletic population.

images Rates as high as 7 per 1000 person-years have been reported in the general population.

images From 10% to 20% of sprains progress to some kind of chronic symptoms.

images Determining whether the patient’s instability is functional (ie, subjective giving way) or mechanical (ie, motion beyond the normal physiologic limits) is important for formulating treatment recommendations.

ANATOMY

images The lateral ankle ligament complex consists of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL), calcaneofibular ligament (CFL), and posterior talofibular ligament (PTFL).

images The ATFL originates from the anterior aspect of the distal fibula and inserts on the lateral aspect of the talar neck. It is often ill defined and, in the chronically sprained ankle, may be manifest as a capsular expansion.

images The ATFL limits anterior translation of the talus with the ankle in neutral and becomes the primary restraint to inversion when the ankle is plantarflexed.

images The CFL originates from the distal tip of the fibula and inserts on the lateral wall of the calcaneus (FIG 1A,B).

images The CFL measures 4 to 6 mm in diameter and 13 mm in length, and is directed posteriorly 10 to 45 degrees from the tip of the fibula.

images The CFL functions to resist inversion with the ankle in neutral.

images The anterior margin of the talus is wider than the posterior margin, which makes the ankle more susceptible to inversion injuries while in plantarflexion.

images The peroneal tendons provide dynamic stability to the ankle joint.

PATHOGENESIS

images An inversion force with the ankle in plantarflexion is the most common mechanism of injury.

images The ATFL typically is the first ligament injured, followed by the CFL.

images Ligament ruptures are most commonly midsubstance tears or avulsions off of the talus.

NATURAL HISTORY

images Despite a relatively high incidence of lateral ankle injuries, most patients do well with nonoperative management.

images Patients are at increased risk for recurrent lateral ankle sprains after sustaining the initial injury and failing to rehabilitate completely.

images Chronic lateral instability may lead to progressive loss of function and osteoarthritic changes of the ankle.

PATIENT HISTORY AND PHYSICAL FINDINGS

images Patients with chronic ankle instability frequently present with pain as well as complaints of multiple sprains caused by minor provocation.

images Duration of symptoms, the type of incidents that cause sprains, the need for functional bracing, and previous treatments are important for determining treatment recommendations.

images If pain is present between episodes of instability, other lesions about the ankle should also be considered.

images An anterior drawer test with a bony endpoint that is distinctly different from that of the contralateral ankle is considered markedly positive.

images Physical examination techniques include the following:

images Palpation. Palpate the ATFL, CFL, syndesmosis, medial and lateral malleoli, peroneal tendons, base of the fifth metatarsal, and anterior process of the calcaneus.

images

FIG 1  The CFL is directly deep to the peroneal tendons as demonstrated by this surgery to repair peroneal tendon dislocation. A. Peroneal tendons in their anatomic location. B. CFL identified when peroneal tendons are retracted.

images

FIG 2  Anterior drawer test. A. Ankle reduced. B. Anterior subluxation.

images Grading ATFL injuries. I, stretching; II, partial tearing; III, complete rupture. This is most useful in the acute setting to determine which structures are injured.

images Anterior drawer test (FIG 2A,B. The ankle is held in plantarflexion, and the talus is translated forward relative to the tibia. With intact medial structures, the displacement is rotatory. Translation of 5 mm more than the contralateral ankle or absolute translation of 9 to 10 mm is a positive test and suggests an incompetent ATFL. Grading ATFL injuries: I, stretching; II, partial tearing; III, complete rupture; most useful in the acute setting to determine which structures are injured.

images Talar tilt. The heel is inverted with the ankle in neutral. Range of motion is compared to the contralateral ankle. Increased inversion is suggestive of a CFL injury.

images Alignment. Assess the standing alignment of the hindfoot. Varus hindfoot alignment predisposes the ankle to inversion injury.

IMAGING AND OTHER DIAGNOSTIC STUDIES

images Standard radiographs should include standing anteroposterior (AP), lateral, and mortise views to evaluate for anterior tibial marginal osteophytes, talar exostoses, osteochondral lesions of the talus, or intra-articular loose bodies.

images Talar tilt can be assessed with inversion stress mortise views of the ankle (FIG 3A).

images Comparison views of the contralateral ankle should also be obtained.

images A talar tilt angle greater than 10 degrees, or 5 degrees greater than the contralateral ankle, is considered pathologic laxity.

images Anterior translation stress radiographs can be obtained by performing the anterior drawer test and shooting a lateral radiograph (FIG 3B).

images Comparison stress views of the contralateral ankle should also be obtained.

images Anterior translation 5 mm greater than the contralateral ankle, or an absolute value of greater than 9 mm is suggestive of instability.

images Stress radiographs may be helpful, but physical examination remains the gold standard for evaluation of instability.

images MRI can be useful to evaluate the ligamentous injury, as well as peroneal tendon pathology and suspected osteochondral injuries.

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS

images Lateral process talar fracture

images Anterior process calcaneus fracture

images Base of the fifth metatarsal fracture

images Tarsal coalition

images Osteochondral lesion of the talus or tibia

images Subtalar instability

images Syndesmosis injury

images Neurapraxia of the superficial peroneal or sural nerve

images Peroneal tendon tear

images Peroneal instability

images Sinus tarsi syndrome

images Anterolateral ankle soft tissue impingement

NONOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT

images Physical therapy should be the initial treatment for patients with chronic instability.

images Proprioceptive training and peroneal tendon strengthening are the most important features.

images

FIG 3  Radiographic stress tests. A. Positive talar tilt test. B.

Positive anterior drawer test.

images

FIG 4  With the patient in the lateral decubitus position, the nonoperated extremity should be well padded. A. Nonoperated leg in a gel pad. B. With the nonoperated leg protected, a platform may be used to facilitate positioning of the operated leg. C. Alternatively: positioning in the lateral decubitus position, using a stack of folded sheets to serve as a rest for the operated leg.

images The duration of therapy varies based on strength deficiencies and the intensity of the program.

images External stabilization of the ankle with taping or bracing can be effective.

images Taping provides tibiotalar stability, but quickly deteriorates with activity.

images Reusable braces provide similar stability, but do not lose effectiveness with activity.

images Orthotic devices and shoe wear modification can also be used when foot or ankle malalignment contributes to the instability.

SURGICAL MANAGEMENT

images If the patient fails 3 to 6 months of conservative treatment and has persistent signs and symptoms of functional and mechanical instability, he or she becomes a candidate for surgery.

Preoperative Planning

images The history must be considered. A relative contraindication for this anatomic repair is generalized ligamentous laxity as might be encountered in Ehlers-Danlos syndrome.

images Carefully review the physical examination. If a varus heel exists, a Dwyer type calcaneal osteotomy should be considered.

images If an osteochondral lesion is present, the ligamentous reconstruction should be done in conjunction with arthroscopic or open treatment of the osteochondral defect.

Positioning

images The patient is placed in the lateral decubitus position with appropriate padding at bony prominences to avoid damage to subcutaneous structures (FIG 4A,B).

images An operative platform is created using bolsters or blankets.

images A “bump” made of four or five towels is used either proximal to the ankle to create a varus or inverted position for better exposure or distal to the ankle to create a valgus or everted position to approximate the edges of the repair (FIG 4C).

Approach

images Two commonly used approaches

images J incision (FIG 5A)

images The incision is made from the distal tip of the fibula along its anterior margin proximally to the level of the ankle mortise.

images Does not afford optimal access to the peroneal tendons

images Curvilinear extensile exposure (FIG 5B)

images Cuvilinear incision over posterior tip of fibular, extending to sinus tarsi area

images Affords comprehensive exposure to anterior ankle, ATFL, CFL, and peroneal tendons

images

FIG 5  A. A traditional J approach on the anterior distal fibula. B. An extensile curvilinear exposure to the lateral ankle. This approach facilitates access to the peroneal tendons should there be associated peroneal tendon pathology.

TECHNIQUES

MODIFIED BROSTROM ANATOMIC LATERAL ANKLE LIGAMENT REPAIR WITH SUTURE ANCHORS

images  Perioperative antibiotics are given.

images  The patient is positioned as described, a thigh tourniquet is placed, and a standard orthopaedic prep and drape is carried out. The tourniquet is inflated.

images  The incision is made as described under Approach in the Surgical Management section (TECH FIG 1A).

images  With the bump placed proximal to the ankle, a dissection is carried out to isolate the inferior extensor retinaculum.

images  The joint capsule is then incised in line with the skin incision and just distal to the leading edge of the fibula. The anterior talofibular (ATF) ligament may or may not be visible as a capsular expansion.

images  The CFL is inspected. This inspection, along with the preoperative evaluation, is used to decide whether or not a repair of this ligament is needed.

images  The joint is inspected for chondral injury.

images  A subperiosteal dissection is carried out at the anterior and lateral aspect of the fibula, raising a flap 3 to 6 mm wide.

images  Using curettes and rongeurs, a trough is made in the anterior and lateral aspect of the fibula at its leading edge, about 3 mm deep and 3 mm wide.

images  If no CFL repair is needed, a single corkscrew anchor double-armed with no. 2 FiberWire (Arthrex, Inc., Naples, FL) suture is inserted centrally in the trough. If a CFL repair is performed, a second anchor, with no. 2 Fiberwire, is used (TECH FIG 1B).

images  The joint is thoroughly irrigated, and the actual repair begins. Move the bump so it sits under the lateral border of the foot, placing the subtalar and ankle joints into an everted position before repairing the CFL if necessary.

images  The capsular and ATF ligament repair is now performed by bringing the sutures from deep to superficial in a horizontal mattress pattern. The “ligament” is shortened by creating the trough at the fibula. If further shortening is needed, the capsule may be trimmed from the distal cut edge.

images  A second reinforcing layer of repair is created by suturing the inferior extensor retinaculum to the periosteal flap with absorbable 2-0 figure 8 sutures.

images  The skin is closed in layers with 3-0 absorbable suture in the subcutaneous suture and staples or subcuticular suture used in the skin.

images  Dressings are applied, and a short-leg non–weight-bearing splint is applied.

Modified Brostrom Anatomic Lateral Ankle Ligament Repair with Suture Anchor(s) (Courtesy of Mark E. Easley)

images  Confirm ankle instability with exam under anesthesia.

images  Approach and exposure

images Curvilinear incision over posterior tip of the fibula and extending to the sinus tarsi (TECH FIG 2)

images Protect sural nerve posteriorly and superficial peroneal nerve anteriorly.

images  Prepare the inferior extensor retinaculum.

images Identify and mobilize the inferior extensor retinaculum (TECH FIG 3AB).

images Relatively thin superficial structure

images  Identify, inspect, and protect the peroneal tendons (TECH FIG 3CD).

images  Anterior arthrotomy

images Detach the capsule, including the ATFL and CFL (TECH FIG 4AB).

images Protect the peroneal tendons (TECH FIG 4C).

images Excise the anterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (Bassett’s ligament) (TECH FIG 4D).

images   Usually present in patients after ankle sprain.

images   Potential for anterolateral soft-tissue ankle impingement.

images Inspect the lateral talar dome for cartilage defect.

images

TECH FIG 1  A. Traditional approach to perform the modified Brostrom repair. B. Suture anchors placed in the distal fibula.

images

TECH FIG 2  Curvilinear extensile exposure to the lateral ankle ligaments.

images  Identify the ATFL and CFL (TECH FIG 5AD); these are condensations within the capsular sleeve.

images  Develop a distal fibular periosteal flap (TECH FIG 6AB) to use as an additional reinforcement of the repair.

images  Prepare anterior distal fibula for reattachment of capsule and ligaments.

images Create a trough using a rongeur (TECH FIG 6C).

images Predrill anatomic footprints for ATFL and CFL suture anchor placement (TECH FIG 6DE).

images  Place suture anchors (TECH FIG 7AB).

images Orient them so that they do not:

images   Interfere with one another

images   Violate the joint

images   Violate the posterior cortex of the fibula and irritate the peroneus brevis

images Test the stability of the suture anchors (TECH FIG 7C).

images   Lift the limb by the anchors; if the anchors are going to fail, we want them to do so now so the problem can be rectified.

images  Pass the respective sutures through the CFL, the ajacent capsule, and the ATFL (TECH FIG 7DF).

images  Test the sutures to ensure that they indeed advance the appropriate portion of the capsule to the desired location on the distal fibula (TECH FIG 7G)

images  Position the ankle properly for securing the sutures (TECH FIG 8A).

images Reduce the talus within the ankle mortise

images Avoid anterior translation of the talus within the mortise

images Dorsiflex the ankle to neutral

images Maintain slight hindfoot valgus

images   Tie the sutures (TECH FIG 8BD).

images  Check the stability of the repair after the anchor sutures have been tied (TECH FIG 8E).

images  Pass the anchor sutures through the distal fibular periosteal flap (TECH FIG 9AC).

images This reinforces the repair

images Place additional sutures from the periosteum to the capsule that has been advanced to the distal fibula (TECH FIG 9D,E)

images Augment the repair further with the inferior extensor retinaculum

images

TECH FIG 3  A,B. Mobilize the inferior extensor retinaculum to be used to augment the repair (Gould modification of the Brostrom procedure). A. Identify the inferior extensor retinaculum. B. Demonstrate that the retinaculum can be advanced. C,D. Identify, inspect, and protect the peroneal tendons. C. Identify the tendons. D. Inspect the tendons.

images

TECH FIG 4  Anterior arthrotomy. A–C. The anterolateral capsule is elevated from the distal fibula. D. With the anterolateral tibiotalar joint exposed, the talar articular cartilage may be inspected and the hypertrophied anterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (Basset’s ligament) may be excised. (Following multiple ankle sprains, anterolateral soft tissue ankle impingement frequently develops).

images

TECH FIG 5  Identify the ATFL and CFL within the lateral capsule; these structures represent condensations within the lateral capsule. A,B. ATFL and its anatomic location on the fibula identified. C,D.CFL identified and its competency tested with ankle/hindfoot inversion.

images

TECH FIG 6  Distal fibular periosteal flap. This flap may be developed to create another layer for repair. A,B. Mobilizing distal fibular flap. C. Using a rongeur to prepare the distal fibula for reattachment of the capsule. D,E. Predrill holes for suture anchors. D. First, drill hole in anatomic footprint of ATFL. E. Second, drill hole in anatomic footprint of CFL.

images

images

TECH FIG 7  Suture anchors. A. First anchor in anatomic footprint of ATFL. B. Second anchor in anatomic footprint of CFL. C. Stability of suture anchors tested by lifting limb from the operating room table by the anchor sutures. D–G. Anchor sutures passed through respective capsular condensations. D. Suture through CFL. E. Suture through posterior aspect of capsule adjacent to CFL. F,G. Suture through ATFL.

images

images

TECH FIG 8  A. Reduce the talus within the ankle mortise before reattaching the ligaments and capsule. The ankle is held in dorsiflexion, with a posterior force maintaining the talus within the ankle mortise. Although covered, a bump has been placed under the distal tibia to allow the heel to translate posteriorly without interfering with the operating table. The heel is maintained in slight valgus. B–D.Secure the sutures while ankle is maintained in optimal position. B. Protect the peroneal tendons. C. Secure the CFL and more posterior capsule. D. Secure the ATFL. E. Recheck the anterior drawer test to determine if the primary sutures are securely maintaining ankle stability.

images

TECH FIG 9  Anchor sutures passed through the periosteal flap to reinforce the repair. A. Sutures through the periosteal flap. B. Check the stability. C. Secure the sutures. D,E. Reinforce the repair with additional sutures. D.Pass sutures from the capsule through the periosteal flap. E. Secure these sutures.

images

TECH FIG 10  Gould modification of the Brostrom procedure. A. Protect peroneal tendons. B. More posterior advancement of the inferior extensor retinaculum. C. Anterior advancement. D. Attempt to cover the permanent anchor sutures with the retinaculum.

images  Protect the peroneal tendons because they are in close proximity to the inferior extensor retinaculum (TECH FIG 10A).

images  Advancing the inferior retinaculum to the distal fibula over the capsular advancement is the (Nathaniel) Gould modification of the Brostrom lateral ankle ligament reconstruction (TECH FIG 10BD).

images  If possible. advance the inferior retinaculum so that the tissue covers the sometimes prominent permanent anchors suture knots. Final check of the anterior drawer and talar tilt to ensure that ankle stability has been reestablished (TECH FIG 11A).

images   Closure (TECH FIG 11B).

images

TECH FIG 11  A. Final check of anterior drawer and talar tilt tests to be sure repair is satisfactory. B. Closure.

MODIFIED BROSTROM BROSTROM-EVANS PROCEDURE

Definition

images  This is a combination of the modified Brostrom procedure described above and the Evans procedure, tenodesing the anterior 50% of the peroneus brevis to the fibula

Indications

images  Athlete or patient in whom greater restraint against inversion is desired

images For example, a football lineman who does not need as much hindfoot flexibility as a running back

images  Anatomic repair planned but greater than anticipated instability, particularly with inversion stress, and an intraoperative determination that more restraint to inversion is needed than can be afforded by the modified Brostrom procedure alone.

images  Lateral ankle instability in a patient with pre-exisiting longitudinal split tear of the peroneus brevis.

Technique

images  Same positioning and approach as for a modified Brostrom procedure

images  The ATFL and CFL are released with the capsular sleeve from the fibula the same way as for the modified Brostrom procedure (TECH FIG 12A)

images  Preparing the peroneus brevis tendon

images The peroneus brevis (PR) is isolated distal and proximal to the superior peroneal retinaculum (SPR) that is left intact

images  The peroneus brevis is split longitudinally and the anterior 50% is released proximally (TECH FIG 12B)

images While keeping the SPR intact, the PR is split using a suture that is passed beneath the SPR that is used to separate the PR into anterior and posterior limbs, acting as a “saw” to divide the tendon along its longitudinal fibers.

images Ater being released proximally the anterior limb of the PR is passed beneath the SPR distally

images  Passing the anterior limb of the PR through the fibula

images Drill an oblique tunnel in the distal fibula (TECH FIG 13A)

images Pass the anterior 50% of the PR through the tunnel from distal to proximal (TECH FIG 13B)

images Complete the modified Brostrom procedure (TECH FIG 13C,D)

images   The ankle is held in neutral position

images   The talus is maintained in the ankle mortise

images

TECH FIG 12  A. Prepare the lateral ankle ligament complex as is done for the isolated modified Brostrom procedure. B. Isolate the anterior 50% of the peroneus brevis tendon.

images

images

TECH FIG 13  A. Transect the anterior 50% of the tendon proximally and pass this half of the peroneus brevis tendon beneath the intact superficial peroneal retinaculum. Drill a fibular tunnel from distal to proximal. B. Pass the anterior slip of the peroneus brevis through the tunnel from distal to proximal. C, D. Complete the modified Brostrom procedure. E, F. After passing through the fibular tunnel, the anterior slip of the peroneus brevis may be folded distally over the fibula to augment the repair. Check the ankle stability: (G) Anterior drawer and (H) inversion stress test.

images Slight valgus is maintained in the hindfoot

images  Augment the modified Brostrom with the Evans modification

images The anterior slip of the PR is secured to the fibular periosteum, both at the anterior and posterior aspects of the tunnel

images   Avoid excessive valgus or excessive tensioning as overtightening could occur; the goal is to have a restraint to inversion, not a complete lack of inversion

images Typically, the anterior slip of the PR can be sewn over the fibula after being passed through the tunnel to further augment the repair (TECH FIG 13E,F)

images  Check ankle stability with anterior drawer and particularly inversion stress (TECH FIG 13G,H)

Postoperative Protocol

images  Same as for modified Brostrom

images

POSTOPERATIVE CARE

images The patient is to remain non–weight-bearing until seen in the clinic for the first cast change in 10 to 14 days.

images At this first postoperative visit, the splint is removed and wound evaluated. If no problems are seen, the skin closure is removed and the patient is placed in a short-leg weightbearing cast for the subsequent 4 to 5 weeks.

images At the next visit the cast is removed and a physical therapy program is initiated for range of motion, proprioceptive training, and progressive resistive exercise.

images Gradual return to sport is possible at 12 to 16 weeks following surgery.

COMPLICATIONS

images Minimal; avoid injury to the superficial peroneal and sural nerves

images Infection

images Wound dehiscence

images Failure of repair

images Peroneal weakness (postoperative physical therapy program important)

images If the talus was not reduced within the ankle mortise when the sutures were secured, then the repair may prove inadequate.

images With an anatomic repair, overtightening is unlikely.

REFERENCES

1.     Black HM, Brand RL, Eichelberger MR. An improved technique for the evaluation of ligamentous injury in severe ankle sprains. Am J Sports Med 1978;6:276–282.

2.     Brostrom L. Sprained ankles: VI. Surgical treatment of chronic ligament ruptures. Acta Chir Scand 1966;132:551–565.

3.     Burks RT, Morgan J. Anatomy of the lateral ankle ligaments. Am J Sports Med 1994;22:7277.

4.     Colville MR. Surgical treatment of the unstable ankle. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 1998; 6:368–377.

5.     Colville MR, Marder RA, Boyle JJ, et al. Strain measurement in lateral ankle ligaments. Am J Sports Med 1990;18:196–200.

6.     Colville MR, Marder RA, Zarins B. Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments: A biomechanical analysis. Am J Sports Med 1992; 20:594–600.

7.     Holmer P, Sondergaard L, Konradsen L, et al. Epidemiology of sprains in the lateral ankle and foot. Foot Ankle Int 1994;15:72–74.

8.     Johnson EE, Markolf KL. The contribution of the anterior talofibular ligament to ankle laxity. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1983; 65A:81–88.

9.     Peters JW, Trevino SG, Renstrom PA. Chronic lateral ankle instability. Foot Ankle 1991;12:182–191.



If you find an error or have any questions, please email us at admin@doctorlib.info. Thank you!